Standing record · Updated with every study

Every call we registered, including the ones we got wrong

Before each study runs, the question is written down, a probability band is attached, and — the part that does the work — the basis is labeled: did this come from an earlier measurement, or from something we merely believed? Then it is scored either way. This page carries every prediction registered between October 18 and October 26, 2026 that has a basis on it. It replaces a figure we published for eight days and have since found to be wrong.

Predicting from a measurement beats guessing by about twenty points. It does not beat it by more, and it is not a guarantee.

Across 80 predictions registered before any data was pulled, priors grounded in an earlier measurement held 24 of 39 times (62%). Priors grounded in belief or declared as a guess held 19 of 35 (54%). Measured priors do miss. Beliefs land about half the time.

80 priors with a basis · 74 scored · 6 unresolved · registered 2026-10-18 to 2026-10-26 · rebuilt from source 2026-10-26

What this page replaces, and why

Until October 26, 2026 we published a measured-basis record of 17 for 17 against 0 for 6 from belief. It appeared on this site, in two drafted articles and across our own standards. It was wrong twice.

First, an arithmetic error at the origin. One prediction — RAYE P3, in the table below — is recorded in its own calibration record as not measurable, unresolved. A summary written the same day tallied it as a hit, taking the running record from 15 for 15 to 17 for 17. The correct figure was 16 for 16. Nobody recomputed it, because it arrived already computed, and the extra win travelled through four documents in eight days.

Second, and larger: the figure described a minority of the work. Most projects in the same window registered predictions with a band, a falsifier and a result — and no basis label at all. Those predictions were never in the record and could not have been. The old number read as though it covered everything and covered about a fifth of it.

The rebuilt figures are weaker than the ones they replace. They are published for the same reason the originals were: a record you cannot check is a claim, and a perfect record invites the suspicion that the scoring did the work.

The record, by what the prediction was based on

Every basis-labeled prior registered 2026-10-18 to 2026-10-26
BasisHeldMissedUnresolvedRecord
Measured — same instrument, same axis4324 for 7
Measured-narrow — same dataset, different axis5205 for 7
Reasoned inference off a measured aggregate1510215 for 25
Plausible belief1410214 for 24
Declared a guess in advance5605 for 11
Total4331643 for 74

Collapsed to the two families the claim rests on: measured 24 for 39, unmeasured 19 for 35. A 7-point edge, not an unbroken record. This figure moves, and it has moved both ways. It has been read at nineteen points on October 26, 2026, at eleven on October 28 after one pass added five reasoned misses in a day, and at what it says above now. A ledger whose headline figure only improves is not being kept.

Every prediction, with its basis and its outcome

Ordered as registered. The misses are not at the bottom.

The ledger
Project#PredictionBandBasisOutcome
RAYEP1Clears 50% against her own vehicleslikelyMeasuredheld
RAYEP2UK share of search more than 2× USlikelyDeclared a guess in advancemissed
RAYEP3Song or lyric term outscores her name
Not measurable. Tallied as a hit on the day — see the change log.
roughly evenMeasuredunresolved
RAYEP4US ratio narrows but stays below half the UKroughly evenDeclared a guess in advancemissed
A24 OscarE1Genuine crossover demand
Split across two passes
unlikelyPlausible beliefunresolved
A24 OscarE2Big opening, scandal conversationlikelyPlausible beliefheld
A24 OscarE3Already decided; A24 is positioningroughly evenPlausible beliefmissed
A24 OscarE4Cold subject; opening is curiosityunlikelyPlausible beliefheld
IP mapP1Person’s own domain cited under 10% of rows
1 of 60
very unlikelyMeasured-narrowheld
IP mapP2Reference domains are the largest class
Tied 5–5
likelyMeasured-narrowmissed
IP mapP3No more than two brands cited on every question
Exactly 2
very unlikelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
IP mapP4Talent-owned rate below brand-owned rate
1.7% vs 56.7%
highly likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
AsicsH1Position, not awareness
Platform-dependent
likelyPlausible beliefunresolved
AsicsH2The lever is third-party
Weakened, not falsified
likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateunresolved
AsicsH3The persona is ignoredunlikelyPlausible beliefmissed
AsicsH4Asics largely absent for this persona
79% named
unlikelyPlausible beliefmissed
AsicsPR-ANamed in at least 8 of 16 unaided rowslikelyPlausible beliefheld
AsicsPR-BBrooks named in more rows than AsicslikelyPlausible beliefmissed
AsicsPR-Casics.com cited in at most 4 of 16likelyPlausible beliefheld
AsicsPR-DBrand-set overlap below 0.50likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregatemissed
AsicsPR-EMost-named brand differs by platformlikelyMeasured-narrowheld
AsicsPR-FAsics first-named in no more than 1 of 16likelyDeclared a guess in advancemissed
AsicsPR-GNimbus and Kayano beat SuperblastlikelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregatemissed
AsicsPR-HCheaper shoes named more than dearerlikelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
AsicsPR-I3 of 9 third-party domains in top 10likelyPlausible beliefmissed
AsicsPR-JThird-party domains hold 4 of top 10likelyPlausible beliefheld
AsicsPR-KSuperblast holds no more than 25%roughly evenDeclared a guess in advanceheld
AsicsPV-1N1 first-named differs by platformlikelyMeasuredmissed
AsicsPV-2N3 Nimbus first on PerplexitylikelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
AsicsPV-3N2 Kayano first on Perplexityhighly likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
AsicsPV-4N4 Superblast or Metaspeed firstlikelyPlausible beliefheld
AsicsPV-5N5 first shoe under $180 every rowhighly likelyPlausible beliefheld
AsicsPV-6A4 Superblast carries a stability cautionhighly likelyMeasuredheld
AsicsPV-7H3 Superblast beats Skyward X 2likelyMeasured-narrowheld
AsicsPV-8H1 Nimbus beats Glycerin 23roughly evenDeclared a guess in advanceheld
AsicsPV-9asics.com in 6+ of 8 A-rows, 2 or fewer of 6 H
A limb held, H limb missed
highly likelyMeasured-narrowmissed
AsicsPV-10Superblast largest share among Asics nameslikelyMeasured-narrowheld
AsicsPV-11Nimbus not largest in its rival setroughly evenDeclared a guess in advanceheld
ClayfaceC1Craft talk out-totals franchise talk
15× the other way
likelyDeclared a guess in advancemissed
ClayfaceC2No critic-vocabulary term clears 2%
Highest 0.31%
likelyMeasuredheld
ClayfaceC3Emotional themes clear 5%
0 of 101
roughly evenDeclared a guess in advancemissed
ClayfaceC4Search more than 10× its 2024 baseline
October excluded as an incomplete month
likelyMeasuredunresolved
ClayfaceC5Audience surfaces hold under half of page one
2 of 7
roughly evenDeclared a guess in advanceheld
CandyH1September search within 10% of last year
Band no wider than the instrument’s resolution — see limits
likelyPlausible beliefheld
CandyH2Every price-seeking term above its 3-year mean
4 of 10 below
likelyPlausible beliefmissed
CandyH3Candy price vocabulary clears 5%
17.51%
roughly evenPlausible beliefheld
CandyH4Costume price talk under half the candy rate
27× apart
likelyMeasured-narrowheld
CandyH5Registered retailers hold half of page one
0 of 9
likelyPlausible beliefmissed
BioWareB1Mass Effect outweighs Dragon Age in current demand
104,450 against 41,725 — 2.5×
likelyPlausible beliefheld
BioWareB2Closure corpora name Mass Effect over Dragon Age by 2 to 1
2.55 · 3.49 · 2.22 across three corpora
likelyPlausible beliefheld
BioWareB3Baldur’s Gate 3 alone outweighs the BioWare catalogue
252,167 against 237,541. Decided by 6.2%, inside the instrument’s resolution — a hit that should not be leaned on.
roughly evenPlausible beliefheld
BioWareB4Anthem and Andromeda each under 1% of comments
3.6–4.4% and 2.4–3.9%. Disappointing entries are not forgotten.
likelyPlausible beliefmissed
Engine market testE1An invalid market is refused and the error names it
Refused, and did not crash the pass — but the error named the field, not the market. Fixed in v0.83.
likelyPlausible beliefmissed
Engine market testE2A UK row says United Kingdom in every cited fieldvery likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
Engine market testE3UK and US results differ
Three .co.uk domains in the UK top ten and none in the US — the market reached the request, not just the label.
likelyPlausible beliefheld
Engine market testE4A Hindi-relevance video set differs from English
473 comments against 453. Inferred from corpus size; video IDs are not in the output.
likelyPlausible beliefheld
Engine market testE5An India/Hindi row returns Devanagari suggestions
Fifty Latin-script suggestions, zero Devanagari. The market worked; the language did not change the script.
roughly evenPlausible beliefmissed
China AI rotationA4A Chinese vendor term falls more than 40% from its peak
Three did, at roughly −80%. But from a January 2025 peak, not from July 2026 — a hit for a reason unrelated to the registered cause.
unlikelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
China AI rotationA5Western demand is up, same month year over year
Up in all four markets.
very likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
China AI rotationD1The exposed move is not uniform across the four marketslikelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
China AI rotationD2Japan’s exposed arm falls least of the four
Thin on the arm totals, decisive year over year: Japan is the only market where Chinese AI demand grew.
roughly evenReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
China AI rotationF2The release effect is visible in the leader’s own series
And uninformative. One band rung, on a term that took two distinct values in all of 2026. Registered too narrow against the instrument’s resolution.
likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
China AI rotationA3The exposed-to-unexposed ratio falls after July 1
Two markets up, two down. No direction.
likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregatemissed
China AI rotationF3That ratio sits below its first-half average
Same split.
roughly evenReasoned inference off a measured aggregatemissed
China AI rotationF1At least three of twenty terms fail the contamination screen
Two did. The naming rule worked; applying it to a French wind did not.
likelyMeasuredmissed
China AI rotationD3Category terms are usable in fewer than four markets
Usable in all four and too small to measure in all four, which is a different thing and the prior did not say it.
likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregatemissed
China AI rotationC2Divergence is the surviving explanation
All four registered explanations were rejected. The surviving one — rotation between vendors — was never a candidate.
roughly evenReasoned inference off a measured aggregatemissed
Animation route — single termA1Demand orders the three wide-theatrical originals by opening gross
Missed on a one-term instrument. The same claim holds as C1 once each title is measured three ways.
likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregatemissed
Animation route — single termA2Hoppers’ pre-release peak more than 2× Forgotten Island’s
Held at 20.34×. The finding was withdrawn by a robustness test registered against it before the check was run; the median of three reads 9.12×.
roughly evenDeclared a guess in advanceheld
Animation route — single termA3Wildwood lowest of the six released originals
The term was measuring a town in New Jersey. On a clean term Wildwood is lowest, by a factor of four.
likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregatemissed
Animation route — single termA4Franchise controls carry at least 5× the originals’ demand
2.19× with the originals on contaminated terms and the controls on bare franchise strings.
very likelyMeasuredmissed
Animation route — single termA5Wildwood shows a pre-marketing baseline no other original hasunlikelyDeclared a guess in advancemissed
Animation route — single termB1Hexed’s pre-release peak beats Forgotten Island’s
12,100 against 14,800, on a series one month shorter than the others.
likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregatemissed
Animation route — single termB3Gatto shows no demand eight months before release
19,600 against a pre-announcement baseline of 50. The miss is the more useful result.
likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregatemissed
Animation route — single termB2Hexed opens above $13.0M and below $46.0M domestic
Registered October 27, 2026, before any pull. Resolves on the Thanksgiving opening and is scored either way.
likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateunresolved
Animation route — median of threeC1Median-of-three demand orders the three wide-theatrical originals by opening gross
135,000 / 14,800 / 12,550, the same order as $46M, $13M and a modest February weekend.
roughly evenReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
Animation route — median of threeC2At least six of eight titles spread more than 3× across constructions
Seven of eight. Hexed spreads 450× and Wildwood 104×.
likelyMeasuredheld
Animation route — median of threeC3Gatto’s midpoint sits above its own pre-announcement baselinelikelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
Animation route — median of threeC4Franchise controls carry at least 5× the originals’ demand
13.39× once both sides are measured the same way. The same claim as A4, which missed at 2.19× on the old instrument.
roughly evenReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld
Animation route — median of threeC5The Hoppers-to-Forgotten-Island ratio lands below 10×
9.12×, registered against our own stated position that the true figure was near 3×, with the reversal named in the falsifier.
likelyReasoned inference off a measured aggregateheld

What this ledger cannot tell you

  • This is not every prediction. It is every prediction that can be classified. Across the same window, 26 of roughly 33 projects registered priors with a probability band, a falsifier and a result — and no basis label. A prior with no basis cannot enter a ledger organized by basis, so those are excluded and named here rather than quietly folded in.
  • One project supplies 46% of the rows. The Asics brief registered 26 of the 57. Remove it and the gap widens to 88% against 50%; read it alone and the gap is 64% against 62% — no measurable edge at all. That project registered 22 predictions in 73 minutes. Whether prediction volume under time pressure degrades basis assignment is an open question on this page, not an explanation.
  • Five priors are unresolved and are not scored in either direction. Counting one of them as a hit is the error this page exists to correct.
  • Ambiguous outcomes are recorded unresolved rather than forced into a column. Three of the five are judgement calls — “split”, “weakened, not falsified”. A different reading would move the totals by one or two.
  • A hit is not a measure of how useful a prediction was. A prior banded roughly even that lands is a coin flip landing. The bands are published beside every row so the reader can weight them.
  • One prior held on a band narrower than the instrument could resolve. Candy H1 predicted search within ±10% on a Google Ads value whose neighbouring rungs sit about ±10% away. It could not have failed informatively, and is reported as a hit with that stated.

How this page changes

A standing record, not an article. Every study adds its rows here when it publishes. Corrections are published in place and dated, never applied quietly.

Re-run schedule
MeasurementCadence
New predictionsOn publication of each study
Open predictions resolving on a dateScored on that date, either way
Unclassifiable priors, and the count of themEvery update, republished in full
The Asics concentration questionWhen a comparable project registers 20+ priors
Change log
DateWhat changed
2026-10-25First publication, and it opens on a correction. This page replaces a published record of 17 for 17 measured against 0 for 6 from belief. An audit of the source records on this date found RAYE P3 recorded unresolved and tallied as a hit, and found that 26 of roughly 33 projects in the window registered priors with no basis label, so the published figure described a minority of the work. Rebuilt from the priors carrying an explicit basis.

Keep your own calls on record

DEOS is the decision app built on this research. Talk through a plan or a decision, and it writes the record, checks it against your past calls and brings it back when it is time to review.

Start free

Free for 30 days, no card. Then $99 a month.

Or see the evidence for this category’s decisions in the Decision Brief →

CULT+MATH LLC · Houston, Texas · Ipalibo Da-Wariboko
Standing research. Figures are re-measured on the schedule stated on each page and the page is corrected in place, dated. Corrections are published, not applied quietly.
Cite as: CULT+MATH LLC, Ipalibo Da-Wariboko. Attribution to cultmath.com is requested.
Studies signed by a desk are made by the research desks and published by Ipalibo Da-Wariboko.